Submission Fees in Literary Publishing: Finding the Right Balance
Oz Osbaldeston
Written by
Published Date
4 mins
Read time
Category
The debate over submission fees in literary publishing touches on fundamental questions about accessibility, sustainability, and the value of creative work. As someone deeply embedded in the literary publishing ecosystem, I've witnessed firsthand how this decision impacts both publications and writers. Let's navigate this complex landscape together.
The Current State of Submission Fees
Literary magazines today operate in a challenging environment where traditional funding sources are increasingly scarce. A quick survey of the landscape reveals:
- 45% of literary magazines charge submission fees
- Average fees range from $2 to $5
- Higher-tier publications may charge up to $25 for special features
- Many offer fee-free submission periods or alternatives
The Case for Submission Fees
Financial Sustainability
Running a literary magazine involves numerous costs that often go unrecognized:
- Editorial staff compensation
- Digital infrastructure maintenance
- Marketing and promotion
- Production costs (for print publications)
- Submission management software
Quality Control
Implementing a nominal fee can:
- Reduce spam submissions
- Encourage writers to submit their best work
- Help cover administrative costs
- Support fair payment for contributors
Professional Development
Fees can enable magazines to:
- Provide detailed feedback
- Offer editorial mentorship
- Maintain higher acceptance rates
- Pay contributors professional rates
The Case Against Submission Fees
Accessibility Concerns
Submission fees can:
- Create barriers for marginalized voices
- Disadvantage emerging writers
- Limit diversity in literary publishing
- Perpetuate existing inequities
Ethical Considerations
Critics argue that:
- Writers shouldn't pay to have their work considered
- Fees can exploit desperate writers
- The model may favor privileged voices
- Alternative funding sources should be explored
Finding Middle Ground: A Hybrid Approach
Many successful literary magazines have adopted nuanced approaches that balance sustainability with accessibility:
Tiered Submission Options
- Standard Free Submissions
- Longer response times
- Basic editorial feedback
- Standard consideration
- Premium Paid Submissions
- Expedited response times
- Detailed editorial feedback
- Special consideration for themed issues
Strategic Fee Implementation
- Fee-free submission periods
- Waiver programs for marginalized writers
- Member/subscriber benefits
- Tiered pricing based on submission type
Setting the Right Price
When implementing submission fees, consider these factors:
Market Analysis
- Research comparable publications
- Understand your target audience
- Consider your publication's prestige
- Evaluate your unique offering
Cost Calculation
Factor in:
- Platform fees (e.g., Send Something subscription)
- Payment processing costs (typically 2.9% + $0.30 per transaction)
- Staff time and resources
- Additional services offered
Recommended Fee Structure
Based on industry standards and operational costs:
Basic Submissions:
- $3-5 for standard submissions
- $0 during designated periods
- Fee waivers for specific groups
Premium Services:
- $10-15 for expedited review
- $15-25 for detailed feedback
- $20-30 for specialized submissions
Implementation Best Practices
1. Clear Communication
- Explicitly state where fees go
- Explain value-added services
- Detail alternative submission options
- Maintain transparency about the process
2. Technology Integration
Using Send Something's platform, you can:
- Set up multiple submission tiers
- Automate fee collection
- Track submission analytics
- Manage fee waivers efficiently
3. Regular Assessment
Monitor and evaluate:
- Submission volume and quality
- Revenue vs. operational costs
- Writer feedback and satisfaction
- Impact on diversity metrics
Making It Work with Send Something
Our platform provides flexible tools to implement your chosen fee structure:
- Customisable Fee Settings
- Set different fees for various submission types
- Implement automatic fee waivers
- Schedule fee-free periods
- Track fee-related analytics
- Secure Payment Processing
- Integration with Stripe
- Automated receipt generation
- Transparent fee breakdown
- Simplified accounting
- Enhanced Value Delivery
- Automated submission tracking
- Integrated feedback systems
- Status update notifications
- Analytics and reporting
Conclusion: A Balanced Approach
The decision to charge submission fees isn't binary. Success lies in finding a model that:
- Supports your publication's sustainability
- Maintains accessibility
- Provides value to writers
- Aligns with your mission
Whether you choose to implement fees or not, the key is to make an informed decision based on your specific circumstances and community needs. Send Something's flexible platform supports whatever approach you choose, helping you focus on what matters most: discovering and sharing great literature.
Want to explore how Send Something can help implement your ideal submission fee structure? Contact us for a personalised consultation.